// Free Gear Checklist
Our free Beginner's Surf Guide has the exact gear checklist — what to buy first, what to skip, and how to pick a board and wetsuit that won't hold you back. Free, instant.
No spam · Instant delivery · Unsubscribe anytime
// 3 Surf shops listed
Boards, wetsuits, wax and ding repair — with ratings, phone numbers and directions for each.
Seasonal averages for New York — not a live surf report for this beach. New York surf seasons in full
// The Lineup
Ranked by rating confidence — review volume counts, not just the score.
1 Cross Hwy
Rentals · Good prices · Friendly staff
Auto-summary of reviews
Customers overwhelmingly praise the staff for being exceptionally friendly, accommodating, knowledgeable, and helpful across sales, rentals, and…
From 4 reviews
Shore Rd
These shops provide essential services including board and wetsuit rentals, ding repairs, and crucially, real-time intel on which breaks are firing—whether it's the consistent beach breaks or the occasional point setups. The local shapers and staff know the sandbars intimately and can steer you toward the best conditions based on swell direction and tide. Beyond the surf, Amagansett delivers that classic East End vibe with farm stands, seafood shacks, and uncrowded beaches compared to neighboring towns. The compact village layout means you can hit multiple shops in one trip, compare gear selections, and tap into decades of collective wave knowledge before paddling out into the surprisingly powerful Atlantic swells that light up this stretch of Long Island's South Fork.
The prime season for consistent surf in Amagansett runs from September through April, benefiting from strong nor'easters and fall swells. Local shops generally maintain fuller inventories and staff during the busy Memorial Day to Labor Day window. Booking lessons or securing peak-time rentals, especially on summer weekends, is best done several days in advance through the five documented local establishments. Before going in, check the local beach forecast and talk to the lifeguard on duty (National Weather Service advice).
Amagansett surf shops provide a range of services essential for the East End conditions. Expect options for surfboard rentals, typically including high-volume foam boards suitable for beginners. Full repair services, including ding repair and wax jobs, are standard offerings. Several local shapers collaborate with these shops, allowing for custom board orders catering to specific local breaks. Insider perks often include tide charts, local break condition reports, and wetsuit fittings necessary for colder water temperatures.
During the summer peak (July/August), water temperatures hover around 68-74°F, requiring just a spring suit or boardshorts. Winter surfing demands serious insulation; expect temperatures to drop to 30-40°F, necessitating a 5/4mm hooded suit, 7mm boots, and gloves.
Yes, nearly all documented surf shops offer package deals that bundle surfboard and wetsuit rentals. This is the most economical option for visitors. Ensure you confirm the size availability for both gear types when reserving, especially during holiday weekends.
The National Weather Service's advice applies here: only swim at a beach with lifeguards, check the local beach forecast and talk to the lifeguard before going in, and remember that rip currents often form on calm, sunny days. If one catches you, don't fight it: relax and float, wave and yell for help, or swim parallel to the beach until you're out of the pull.
