Amagansett Beach and Bicycle Company

Surf shop in Amagansett, NY

SurfSpotGuide verified

4.9 (50 reviews)

Amagansett, NY

About Amagansett Beach and Bicycle Company

Amagansett Beach and Bicycle Company in Amagansett, NY, offers rentals and sales for bikes, sea kayaks, and related gear. Customers consistently praise the exceptionally friendly, knowledgeable, and accommodating staff who provide high-quality, well-maintained equipment and efficient service. This shop is ideal for families and visitors needing reliable rentals or expert advice for exploring the local Hamptons routes.

The Good

Customers overwhelmingly praise the staff for being exceptionally friendly, accommodating, knowledgeable, and helpful across sales, rentals, and repairs. Specific highlights include excellent service for last-minute requests, going above and beyond (e.g., driving customers to urgent care, fixing flats on the road), high-quality and well-maintained rental bikes, efficient pick-up/drop-off processes, and great advice on routes. Many reviewers consider this the best bike shop they have encountered.

Things to Consider

One customer reported a negative experience regarding perceived unfair billing after gifting the shop valuable vintage bikes, feeling they received zero 'hook up' or leeway on a minor repair charge ($130 for brake adjustment and new tires). Otherwise, no significant recurring negative feedback regarding service or equipment quality was found.